Live

Live: Sunday Paper Review

01:00 PM-02:00 PM

Live: Sunday Paper Review
Advertisement
Rugby

WATCH: Controversial penalty try seals Scottish win over England

Scotland retained the Calcutta Cup after a tense victory over England in the opening round of the Guinness Six Nations.



WATCH: Controversial penalty t...
Rugby

WATCH: Controversial penalty try seals Scottish win over England

Scotland retained the Calcutta Cup after a tense victory over England in the opening round of the Guinness Six Nations.

England had all of the momentum in the first half, playing most of the rugby in the right areas. However, Scotland went into the lead with the first try of the match.

With just under 20 minutes payed, Darcy Graham received the ball, broke into a half gap and set up debutant Ben White for the try. It was converted by Finn Russell, taking a four-point lead.

While the two sides traded penalties for the remainder of the half, it was Russell's boot that sent Scotland into half time maintaining that four-point lead.

However that lead was short-lived. As he so often has been in the last two years, Marcus Smith made the difference for England to put them into a seven-point lead with less that 20 minutes to play.

Then came the moment of biggest controversy. Former Scotland and Leinster coach Matt Williams, speaking on Virgin Media, suggested that England were 'robbed' as Scotland were awarded a penalty try.

Luke Cowan-Dickie was sent off for a deliberate knock-on into touch, with the referees deeming the situation would have lead to a try had it not been for the actions of the English hooker.

However, Williams believes that it was an incredibly harsh call, stating that 'a try would not have definitely been awarded' following the actions of Cowan-Dickie.

"He certainly looked like he didn't understand the laws of the game," Williams said. "However, I've got to say I've seen some dodgy penalty tries, and that's right up there.

"I'm not so certain that you could say a try was definitely going to be scored from that. Did the foul play stop a try from definitely being scored? I just don't think it fulfilled those requirements."

 

Rob Kearney, who joined Williams in the post-match breakdown on Virgin Media, believed that Cowan-Dickie definitely cost his side the win.

"He'd done all the hard work," Kearney said. "He'd timed his jump into the air really well. He'd put his two hands up in the air, and then just decided to bat it into touch.

"It was absolutely crazy stuff. You are always loathed to put the blame on one person... but. He has cost his team this game."

Russell soon after put Scotland into a three-point lead, with nine minutes left in the game.

The hosts managed to maintain their lead with some strong set piece performances.

In the end, it was a scrum which was reset several times that put Scotland over the line. A turnover from the subsequent English move fell into Scottish hands.

Stuart Hogg booted the ball dead to maintain the Calcutta Cup and keep their hopes of a Six Nations championship alive for 2022.

Player Ratings | Big Mack Hansen is loving it as Ireland punish Wales

Vodafone. Main sponsor of the Irish rugby team. #TeamOfUs

Download the brand new OffTheBall App in the Play Store & App Store right now! We've got you covered!

Subscribe to OffTheBall's YouTube channel for more videos, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter for the latest sporting news and content.


Read more about

Calcutta Cup England Finn Russell Luke Cowan-Dickie Marcus Smith Scotland Six Nations Stuart Hogg